Spirit Island Expansions Guide: Which Ones Are Worth It?

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases and sometimes recommend products from other sellers at no extra cost you. For more details see my disclosure policy and privacy policy.

You have played Spirit Island enough times that the base game spirits feel like old friends, and now the expansion shelf is staring at you. Four big boxes, a standalone spin-off and a pair of promo packs is a lot of cardboard to sort through, and not every box earns its place on the table. I will save you the guesswork: buy Branch and Claw first, Jagged Earth second, and treat everything after that as optional.

Here is how each one changes the game, who it suits, and where your money does the most good.

🌿 The Short Answer

If you want the buy order without the reasoning, here it is.

  • First: Branch and Claw, the small box that sets up everything else.
  • Second: Jagged Earth, the big one and the best value.
  • Third: Feather and Flame, if you want more spirits and a few extra twists.
  • Last: Nature Incarnate, for experienced groups who already own Jagged Earth.
  • Only if it fits: Horizons of Spirit Island, which is a gift or a teaching tool rather than an upgrade.

That order is not the order the boxes came out in by accident. Each one leans on the last, so skipping around costs you more than it saves.

Everything Is A Game

The Gambit Vault

Board game accessories for players who care about the table.

🔥 Branch and Claw: Start Here

Branch and Claw is the smallest expansion by a distance, and that is its strength. It adds two spirits, Sharp Fangs Behind the Leaves and Keeper of the Forbidden Wilds, plus the French Plantation Colony adversary.

The real contribution is four new token types: Strife, Wilds, Beasts and Disease. Some of them stop Invaders from exploring, building or ravaging, while others drop wild Beasts into a land. New Fear and Blight cards and scenarios round out the box.

Why does it come first? Later expansions assume you know these tokens. Jagged Earth uses Branch and Claw terminology and icons without requiring the box, and one reviewer at Gideon’s Gaming says Jagged Earth can feel awkward and janky without it.

It is also an easy first step. Two spirits and a handful of tokens add variety without turning setup into a project.

Buy it if you want to stretch the base game a little before committing to a bigger box. Skip it only if you are certain you are heading straight to Jagged Earth, and even then I would grab both.

🌋 Jagged Earth: The One That Changes Everything

Jagged Earth is the expansion most people mean when they say Spirit Island has endless replay value. It adds ten spirits, two adversaries (the Habsburg Monarchy and the Tsardom of Russia) and three scenarios.

It also adds a new event deck that shakes up each turn, Badlands tokens that make Dahan and Invaders take extra damage, and aspect cards that modify the low-complexity base game spirits. Two extra island boards let you play with five or six players.

That last point matters for groups. If your usual table is three or four, you will not use the larger player count often, but the aspects and events change every game regardless of headcount.

Be honest with yourself about the learning curve, though. Reviewers rate it as heavy, and Badlands in particular create fiddly interactions that take a game or two to absorb.

If you want to know how those new adversaries compare with the French one, our Spirit Island adversaries ranked guide covers the order to try them in. This post will not re-rank them.

Buy it if you want the single biggest jump in variety and you are comfortable with a heavier rules load. This is the best value in the line.

🦅 Feather and Flame: A Pleasant Add-On

Feather and Flame is where the line gets more modest. The box adds four spirits, one adversary, two scenarios and five aspects, and it contains the content of the two earlier promo packs sold as a single bundle.

That last detail answers the promo pack question. If you see Promo Pack 1 or 2 secondhand, you do not need them separately, because their spirits live in Feather and Flame.

The mechanical changes here are lighter than in Jagged Earth. You get fresh spirits to try and a few extra scenario and adversary options, but the way the game plays does not shift in a big way.

It suits players who have already worked through the spirits they own and want a few more voices at the table. It does not suit anyone hoping for a new rules layer.

Buy it third, once Branch and Claw and Jagged Earth have both seen real table time. Skip it if you are still discovering what is in the first two boxes.

🌳 Nature Incarnate: For Veterans With Jagged Earth

Nature Incarnate is the most specialist box in the line, and it comes with a hard requirement: you need both the base game and Jagged Earth to use it.

It adds eight spirits, a new adversary, two scenarios, a stack of aspects and twelve Major Power cards but no new Minor Powers. The headline mechanic is Incarna, a token that counts as presence and gives a spirit a physical piece on the board. Four of the new spirits depend on it.

The spirits skew complex. A review at Board Game Quest counts three moderate, four high and one very high complexity, which is a steep ask for anyone still finding their feet.

That reviewer calls the expansion optional, and I agree. It is a lovely box for a group that has played dozens of games and wants new puzzles, but it adds spirits rather than fixing anything.

Buy it last, and only if your group enjoys complex spirits. Pass if you are newer to the game or would rather have more Power cards than more spirits.

🐦 Horizons of Spirit Island: A Different Kind of Purchase

Horizons of Spirit Island is a standalone game rather than an expansion. It includes five low-complexity spirits and uses a pared-back set of mechanics, which makes it an easier way into the game.

For base game owners that makes it a niche buy. You already know how to play, so the main value is as a teaching tool for a nervous friend or a gift for someone who has not tried the game.

I would not buy it to expand your own collection. If you want help guiding a newcomer through their first game, our Spirit Island beginner’s guide is a better place to start.

⏱️ Complexity and Table Time

Every expansion adds something to setup and teardown, and that cost adds up faster than most people expect. Branch and Claw barely registers. Jagged Earth adds noticeably more cards and tokens to sort before each game, and Nature Incarnate adds more again.

Teaching time grows too. A group happy with the base game can absorb Branch and Claw in one session, but Jagged Earth is worth introducing a piece at a time. Add aspects first, then events, then Badlands once everyone is comfortable.

A practical tip: you do not have to shuffle every expansion deck into every game. Many players keep a lean setup for weeknights and open the full box only when they have a long evening ahead.

🧭 Matching the Expansion to Your Group

The buy order above works for most people, but your table might push you in a different direction. A few quick patterns help.

  • You want more variety: Branch and Claw plus Jagged Earth. Nothing else comes close for the money.
  • You want a tougher challenge: Jagged Earth, then Nature Incarnate. Pair the new spirits with the toughest adversaries, and use our strategy guide to sharpen your plans.
  • You play with newer players: Stop after Branch and Claw until everyone is comfortable. Add Jagged Earth when the group asks for more.
  • You mostly play solo or in pairs: Jagged Earth still pays off through aspects and events. The extra island boards matter less.

Bigger groups bring their own pitfalls. If one confident player keeps steering the whole table, our piece on the alpha player problem in cooperative games is worth a read before you add more complexity.

💡 What I Would Actually Do

If I were standing in a shop with a limited budget, I would buy Branch and Claw and Jagged Earth together. That pair gives you the tokens, the events, the aspects and twelve extra spirits, and the two boxes fit together as a unit.

Spend a month with that setup before you buy anything else. You will quickly learn whether you want more spirits (Feather and Flame, then Nature Incarnate) or whether the pair is enough.

Many groups stop there and never feel short. Spirit Island is a game that rewards depth with what you own more than it rewards owning everything.

If you are weighing the game against other co-op heavyweights before committing more money, our Pandemic vs Spirit Island vs Gloomhaven comparison lays out the trade-offs. Players who enjoy buying into a deep system might also like our guides to Gloomhaven expansions and Eldritch Horror expansions for how those lines handle the same decision.

🎲 Final Thoughts

The best Spirit Island expansion is the one that matches what your table is missing. For most groups that means Branch and Claw first, Jagged Earth second, and a long pause before anything else.

Feather and Flame and Nature Incarnate are good boxes for people who love the game and want more spirits. Horizons is for sharing the game with someone new. Buy in that order, and you will always be adding to something you already enjoy.

🧭 Continue Your Journey